― This pie. This pie came about when DH and I were taste testing Barney Butter. It was smooth and creamy where it needed to be. The crunchy almond pieces gave it a great "just like chunky peanut butter" taste. So good, even I could eat it off of a spoon. I would not do that with peanut butter. ∙ DH said, "you should make a pie with this. I love peanut butter pie." OK. I have never made or HAD a peanut butter pie. I'm not a fan of peanut butter. I would never opt to [...].